» A blogger was alerted three hours before the tsunamis

A blogger was alerted three hours before the tsunamis

 Neis Bulletin Neic Slav Fig72Hi-ResPhilsland (in French) is a subscriber to an earthquake prevention alert: USGS earthquake. He was warned about the earthquake three hours before the waves touched the coasts:

“A great earthquake occurred at 00:58:49 (UTC) on Sunday, December 26, 2004. The magnitude 9.0 event has been located OFF THE WEST COAST OF NORTHERN SUMATRA. (This event has been reviewed by a seismologist.)”

How amazing is this ? In three hours thousands of casualties could have been avoided if they were warned earlier. Now Internet is everywhere and especially where the tourists were staying, we could have avoided many deaths. What do you think, Robert ?

Update:

The Hindustantimes says India was not alerted by warning systems

Newindpress.com says

“Within 15 minutes of the earthquake, scientists running the tsunami warning system for the Pacific had issued a cautionary from their Honolulu hub, to 26 participating countries. India was not among them.”

“The irony could not have been sharper. One of the people who helped set up the Pacific Tsunami Warning System and the Canadian Tsunami Warning System three decades ago was a Canada-based Indian, Tad Murty.”

” in spite of speeds of 400-500 miles per hour, it is possible to make warnings practicable.”

“Now attached to the University of Manitoba, Winnipeg, Murty says key equipment and computer models could have helped save thousands in southeast Asia on Sunday. He has personally taken up the issue of setting up a 24-hour tsunami warning system with the Indian government.”



  • http://www.boingboing.net/2004/12/27/tsunami_blog_coverag.html Boing Boing

    Tsunami blog coverage: updates

    Rohit Gupta, Jon Lebkowsky, and Dina Mehta at the Worldchanging.com blog have just published a roundup of first-person accounts, aid site urls, and news reports related to the tsunami disaster in Asia. They say this post will be updated regularly, so …

  • http://www.boingboing.net/2004/12/27/tsunami_blog_coverag.html Boing Boing

    Tsunami blog coverage: updates

    Rohit Gupta, Jon Lebkowsky, and Dina Mehta at the Worldchanging.com blog have just published a roundup of first-person accounts, aid site urls, and news reports related to the tsunami disaster in Asia. They say this post will be updated regularly, so …

  • Jorge Ortiz

    Perhaps it is time to create Earthquake/Tsunami Alert Internet Appliances. Some goverments (i.e. Mexico City) have been unwilling to create automatic alert systems, for fear that real or false alerts may cause more damage than good (or that politicians will look incapable of acting or do any good in the face of alerts). This is a good time for citizens to take the problem with their own hands and use the Internet as the medium to bypass goverments and propagate alerts.

  • http://www.la-grange.net/ karl

    It’s not directly related. An earthquake does not cause always a tsunami. This one has created one. There’s no tsunami detection system in the indian ocean because it’s very rare not like in Japan.
    All people have been surprised. Read my weblog. People didn’t make the connection between the Tsunami and the earthquake. In Malaysia, Tourists hotels in Penang have been warned when the Tsunami hit the Langkawi island, then many tourists when outside of the beach, though they were still families on a beautiful sunday.
    You can ‘t evacuate an warned population for something first you don’t know in places with fishing villages and no internet connections. That’s the real world. Thousands of people and all their belongings in a few hours. It’s impossible and you can bet on the robbery.
    The earthquake was not necessary an alert of the tsunami. It’s just a possibility.

  • http://wilordw.blogspot.com/2004/12/blogger-was-alerted-three-hours-before.html wilordw

    A blogger was alerted three hours before the tsun

    Via Loic Le Meur Blog,
    When I read thru all the blogs that posting about this disaster and you can noticed that maybe death toll can be lower with

  • rbelkin

    There are literally thousands of islands out in the Indian Ocean.
    The tsunami threat in the Indian Ocean was deemed a low possibility.
    There are islands where communications with the outside world is pretty minimal – let alone with small boat fisherman.
    And as others mentioned, on a beatiful sunny day – how likely are you to believe there’s a 40-foot wave coming towards you over some scratchy radio?
    Obviously this was a wake up call that there should be such a system but for some if not many on a tiny island or a cove or in a small fishing boat, where do you run from a 500 MPH 40-foot wave?
    It covered 750 miles in 100 minutes.
    It is a tragedy and hopefully this will be the last of such huge porportions but we cannot prevent every tragedy.

  • Loic

    I agree, I was just thinking how sad it was that many people knew about the events 3 hours before they happened. Sad, really, even though there is very little that could have been done. Thanks for your comments.

  • http://scoble.weblogs.com Robert Scoble

    Well, I’ve said enough on this topic. My heart goes out to all those affected.

  • http://jimmiz.blogg.de/eintrag.php?id=761 jimmiz journal

    Blogs und der Tsunami

    dogfood darüber:
    Die Tsunami-Katastrophe zeigt nicht nur, das Blogs mitunter als journalistisches Instrument benützt werden können, sondern auch als verne…

  • http://www.jomiha.com/blog Jonathan Hawkins

    I have been talking to my Sri Lankan colleague, and he described to me that one of the biggest problems was the lack of knowledge amongst the population. Someone earlier (loic, and karl) mentioned that essentially the problem was that exact thing. My Sri Lankan friend said that since there hadn’t been a tidal wave ever there (actually not since Krakatoa), no one knew that when they felt the earth shake they might want to go to higher ground. What an incredible tragedy. It boggles the mind. I have no idea even how to respond when he tells me about his close personal friend who lost 23 family members in one horrifying wave. Ugh.

  • http://seekirchen.blogs.com/clogm/2004/12/_thailand_hilfe.html cLOGm

    | thailand hilfe – update |

    wenn es einen ort gibt an dem sich information den gegebenheiten schnell anpasst, dann ist das das internet. und nichts verbreitet sich schneller als information in weblogs. und also gibt es natürlich zum schweren erdbeben in südostasien schon jede m…

  • http://www.thepoliticals.com/2004/12/tsunami_disastr.html ThePoliticals

    Tsunami: disastro evitabile?

    via Marco Montemagno: Consiglio di leggere questo articolo del New York Times

  • http://etage.gokboet.nu/arkiv/001574.php e.t a g e

    Katastrof

    Det är fortfarande svårt att förstå hur omfattande katastrofen egentligen är. Trots att nyheterna talar om det om och om igen. Man liksom förstår utan att förstå. Så många döda och sakna…

  • http://etage.gokboet.nu/arkiv/001574.php e.t a g e

    Katastrof

    Det är fortfarande svårt att förstå hur omfattande katastrofen egentligen är. Trots att nyheterna talar om det om och om igen. Man liksom förstår utan att förstå. Så många döda och sakna…

  • Loic

    Jonathan, I understand you have no idea what to respond… I think like Robert, I will stop blogging about the events and have my heart go to the victims and their families.

  • http://www.GlobalSurfNetwork.com Rob Beedie

    EARTHQUAKES, Industry, PEOPLE,
    Isn’t it strange that all governments can allot and find billions of dollars to fight wars for whatever reasons but the very same leaders can’t find the necessary resources to help in time of human disaster without the help of the common everyday person;both in labor and finances. ALL DONATIONS ACCEPTED, please give.
    The people from all countries always give because we all fell each others suffering.
    Our prayers are genuine not just token gestures around election time or during a national crisis. Our names don’t have to be plastered in the headlines, we need no pat on the back because we afterall are just “the people”. We pray together,we suffer together but most of all we work and produce together while most of the nations and its leaders do just the opposite.
    They all can find money to build defense systems to warn them about incoming missles.
    Wow, what a novel idea, put that energy,that very same energy into warning systems to help prevent national and global tragedys such as what is happening in Indonesia right now. The United Nations has meetings to discuss global commercializtion, the invasion of Iraq, the war on terror and even in their infamous wisdom they have corrupted goals because they are rooted in deceit and lack of trust amongst its own so called world leaders. Until all world leaders put the people first all systems will fail even the war sysytem that they all cherish so much. It will even eventually turn directly back on them and when it does who will they run to – you guessed it – us THE PEOPLE. So, this is enough for now and I’ll close in prayer that God intervenes for all of us and PEACE will bless each of us. May God bless all of those suffering from this world event and once again may the power of the global citizens suggest to there own governments to stretch out the helping had and comfort the suffering TODAY, tomorrow may be too late. Each of us should fight the most destructive war which lives deep inside each of us. By doing that we end up doing the right things and the right thing is God’s work. Regardless of what nation we come from each of us is very capable of doing just that because with God’s help we can. Minds and hearts are changed through prayer. God hears prayer and will heal the suffering, he will comfort the sick,and he will rebuid nations or destroy them at will, his will. But most of all he will send his army of volunteers from all nations to spread compassion and love. I challenge all nations to allow this energy to be released on Indonesia and help others heal through sharing compassion,love,and resources. ( food for thought )

  • Whoever

    Loic, you’re lovely and can hardly be accused of being a naive person but don’t you think that those millions that are now homeless had the Internet ????? This is the most awkward statement you’ve made because most of them don’t even have a phone.

  • Diana

    I just read in the Daily Mail that in fact this warning had been passed on to broadcasters but fears of damaging the tourism economy with alarmist predictions took precedence and the warning was under-emphasized. Typical.

  • Loic

    “Whoever” mr anonymous yes, we could not have saved many people. But it was 4 hours before the Maldives were hit for example. A lot can be done in 4 hours I think ?
    Yes, the entire world is not Internet ready, I know. The governments, hotels, main cities, are.

  • Loic

    Please check in the post the update I just made with press articles from India who seem to confirm thousands of deaths could have been avoided if India was warned.

  • http://blog.derekrose.com derek

    I’m rather skeptical of this “three hours” claim. The earthquake hit at 00:58 UTC; the Pacific Tsunami Warning Center did not issue a bulletin warning of the possibility of a tsunami near the epicenter until more than an hour later, at 02:04 UTC. (and at that time they thought it was an 8.5-magnitude earthquake- it wasn’t revised to a 9.0 until about 18 hours later).

    The tsunamis, meanwhile, hit Sumatra about half an hour after the earthquake and Thailand within two hours … see graphic here.

    The only way a blogger could have known about the tsunamis three hours before they hit is if he had received a sign from God…

  • http://www.microsiervos.com/msmt/archivo/terremotos_y_maremotos_en_asia.html Microsiervos

    Terremotos y maremotos en Asia

    En Seismic Monitor del consorcio IRIS se puede ver de forma muy gráfica cómo de enorme ha sido el reciente terremoto de 8,9 en la escala de Richter en la isla de Sumatra, que está entre los cinco más grandes…

  • Paul

    Get real. A warning system may alert some people (ie. foreign tourists) in major centres. These would be the least affected as they will be ferried back to their own countries and safe homes while the locals are left homeless. It amazes me that this is such a major issue for some people when in reality it will do litte for those most affected by a tsunami in these areas.

  • http://blog.derekrose.com derek

    Paul, wouldn’t you rather be left homeless than dead? Most of the Pacific subscribes to a tsunami warning center. It’s just a question of erecting sirens and having a system to alert local media and the authorities. Oh and also tidal gauges, so officials can tell a sea surge is coming. People only needed to be a few hundred yards inland to survive the tsunamis, from the reports I’ve read.

    Tsunamis are very rare in the Indian Ocean, so the governments of those countries apparently thought they could do without a warning system.

  • george hill

    Hi, I wanted to ask if anyone else heard this report I heard on the BBC. It was reported that the United Nations medical teams are allowing survivors of the tsunami to die in order to exaggerate the affect of the tsunami. Thousands of people who were found alive were never rescued and allowed to die.

  • http://thefoolwonders.blogspot.com/ John Bartram

    Thank you for bringing this to our attention.
    I see that many still struggle to accept the horrific truth: that it was people who made a regional catastrophe out of a local disaster.
    OK, so some people could not connect a niner quake under the sea with the tidal wave… not very bright, but I don’t expect too much from governments. But after the wave struck Thailand, there were 2.5 hours to phone India and Sri Lanka, and longer yet to warn African states.
    Some cannot see how they could have issued a warning. Well, I can. Radio would have done the job – the BBC World Service covers the region (and globe). Satellite TV – CNN, Sky etc – would have done. A broadcast warning would have saved 80-90%.
    A new detection system system would be nice, but as its builder says, the warning still has to be disseminated and that’s down to the authorities.
    My own weblog has more on this:
    http://thefoolwonders.blogspot.com/

  • http://radio.weblogs.com/0132329/2004/12/28.html#a511 Georg Berg’s Notizen

    Tsunami blog coverage: updates

    Xeni Jardin : Rohit Gupta, Jon Lebkowsky, and Dina Mehta at the Worldchanging.com blog have just published a roundup of first-person accounts, aid site urls, and news reports related to the tsunami disaster in Asia.

  • http://www.typepad.com/t/trackback/1591213 Mother day gift weight loss pill ringtones nautica

    Phentermine macintosh notebook computer phentermine online

    Search: phentermine, buy phentermine, phentermine online, gifts, weight loss, ringtones, nautica, diet pills…

  • http://profile.typekey.com/icewatto/ WATTO

    Sports Pool Play for FREE in our Office Pool, and win FREE weekly prizes. Play FREE now! http://www.officepoolgaming.com/

  • http://www.bangkoklodge.info/hotels-in-bangkok/hotel-in-thailand/ Hotel In Thailand

    Hotel In Thailand

    Phuket, hotel, Thailand, resorts, tours and travel information guide, with photo tours and beach

  • emily

    i think the event is tragic, just talking about it makes me feel so fortunate in so many ways…hoping that the people that experienced the tsunami will know that the world is trying to help

  • http://find-at.entromall.org/switerzland.html Plummer

    Hi!!! Very nice design, by the way!!! I think … What do you think about my?

  • http://www.movabletype.org/members/adipexphentermine Adipex phentermine.

    Adipex.

    Difference between adipex. Phentermine adipex bontril didrex. Rx adipex. Adipex. Adipex dangers. Adipex large order.

  • http://www.movabletype.org/members/tramadolhcl Tramadol saturday delivery.

    Tramadol.

    Ratio of tramadol. Tramadol cod. Tramadol side effects. Tramadol hcl. Tramadol. Tramadol cheap no rx.

  • http://www.movabletype.org/members/porn Free porn.

    Free daily porn.

    Free porn.

  • http://www.movabletype.org/members/amoxicillin4u Amoxicillin.

    Amoxicillin for acne.

    Buy amoxicillin without prescription. Amoxicillin. Amoxicillin for acne. Amoxicillin dosage. Amoxicillin floppy baby. Infant amoxicillin reactions. Amoxicillin side effects. Amoxicillin online no prescription.

  • http://www.movabletype.org/members/vigaraonline Viagra without a prescription.

    Try viagra for free.

    Buy viagra in canada. Viagra.

  • http://www.movabletype.org/members/Levitra4u Levitra attorneys.

    Levitra cialis viagra.

    Generic levitra. Compare levitra cialis. Levitra. Buy levitra online.